The Student News Site of North Carolina A&T State University

The A&T Register

The Student News Site of North Carolina A&T State University

The A&T Register

The Student News Site of North Carolina A&T State University

The A&T Register

    Troy Davis: Just another victim of our leagal system

    As the potassium chloride

    progressively silenced the tune of Troy Davis’ heart, political

    tension and feelings of animosity climaxed amongst protesters as a

    potentially innocent man met his demise at the hands of the United

    States Government on Sept. 21.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>As the potassium chloride progressively silenced

    the tune of Troy Davis’ heart, political tension and feelings of

    animosity climaxed amongst protesters as a potentially innocent man

    met his demise at the hands of the United States Government on

    Sept. 21.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Senator John Kerry once summarized the death

    penalty in the statement, “A humane and generous concern for every

    individual, his health and fulfillment, will do more to soothe the

    savage heart than the fear of state-inflicted death, which chiefly

    serves to remind us how close we remain to the jungle.”

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Davis supposedly shot and killed an off duty

    police officer in a Burger King parking lot. The gun was never

    found and the prosecution against Davis was completely based on

    witness testimonies. Many of the witnesses recanted their stories

    and stated in sworn affidavits that they were pressured into

    testifying against Davis by police.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Capital punishment is an ineffective tactic for

    deterring crime and is used discriminatorily against minorities,

    particularly black who commit crimes against whites. The death

    penalty has been inflicted at significantly higher rates on

    minorities, specifically African-Americans.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>In fact, George Baldus and statistician George

    Woodworth found that death penalty odds are 3.9 times higher if the

    defendant is black.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>After acknowledging such a staggering statistic,

    one might question who makes the critical decisions regarding who

    lives and who dies.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Recent studies found that the district attorneys

    who make the final decision in death penalty cases in the United

    States are 98 percent white and one percent African American. The

    extreme disparities between the percentages explain the racially

    biased implementation of the death penalty. It seems that racially

    charged discrimination rooted in the 1600s is still prevalent in

    today’s “color-blind” society.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Death penalty expert, Richard Dieter, found that

    blacks who kill whites were more likely to receive the death

    penalty than any other offender-victim combination. 

    It is quite possible that if Troy Davis had chosen to murder a

    black police officer the district attorney would have allowed him

    to perish in a cell.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Dieter also found that black defendants on

    average are faced with a distinctly higher chance of receiving the

    death penalty than all other similarly situated defendants. Such

    findings point to a judicial system that is inclined and influenced

    by historically consistent racial prejudices.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>The implementation of the death penalty is

    somewhat if not completely biased towards white

    Americans.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>The threat of death by execution does not deter

    capital crimes more than imprisonment. Clever conservatives use

    such persuasive political clichés to amplify this plausible concept

    and to justify their positions, but the facts do not support

    it.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>An overwhelming majority of capital crimes are

    not premeditated and normally occur in the heat of the

    moment.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Hence, the fear of the death penalty will seldom

    influence an offender to restrain from committing a capital

    crime.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Hugo Adam Bedau, a death penalty expert, found

    that only two percent of those convicted of criminal homicide are

    sentenced to the death penalty. Therefore, even the infrequent

    person who somehow evaluates the risk of the death penalty before

    committing a murder would probably expire in an eight by ten cell

    block if they play their cards right.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Without mentally analyzing the possibility of

    receiving the death penalty, capital punishment has no significance

    or use as a deterrent of capital offenses.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>According to Amnesty International findings,

    murder rates in death penalty states have consistently been

    slightly higher than those in abolition states. Unfortunately, this

    proves that if a person feels that it is necessary to take a life,

    he or she will take a life.  Fear is not an element

    within the mind of a bonafide murderer, whether he or she is in a

    death penalty state or not.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Death penalty supporters often preach that the

    death penalty will decrease the number of assaults on police

    officers. In fact, there have been more assaults on police officers

    in states that still implement  the death penalty than

    in states that have abolished the death penalty.  The

    death penalty has never and never will keep a criminal from

    engaging in a criminal act of any kind.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>A compilation of racially biased death penalty

    statistics serve as evidence of the racism and prejudice that has

    plagued the United States for centuries.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>In a country supposedly founded on Christian

    principals, our leaders choose to send a message of the

    permissibility of murder when it is used in an effort to solve

    social problems.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>The Fourteenth Amendment of the United States

    Constitution is violated when a convicted person is stripped of the

    possibility of new evidence being presented or legal ramifications

    that could warrant a reversal or release.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>The concept of due process under the law has

    been overlooked for years and could have saved Troy Davis’

    life.

    “font-size: 12pt;”>Whether Davis or any other death row inmate in

    the United States is guilty or not, the bottom line is that the

    death penalty is irrevocable and a mistake cannot be

    pardoned.

    • Kalyn Hoyle, Contributor